| Norman E. Sutton | — |
| Frank A. Weidknecht III | — |
| Edward C. Dunbar | January 1973 |
| Francis H. Strouse | January 1976 |
| John B. Fuhrmann | January 1979 |
| Jerome J. Davidson | May 1983 |
| Alfred R. Dorf | June 1984 |
| John F. Kraus | July 1985 |
| George D. Muller | May 1986 |
| J. Kirby Fowler | March 1987 |
| Richard F. Sollner – 3 PHF’s | February 1988 |
| Kenneth P. Ball | June 1988 |
| Mary Sollner | June 1988 |
| Charles H. Fisher | August 1990 |
| John Orzano | August 1990 |
| Peter Cantlay | 1991 |
| John J. Zullo | December 1991 |
| James F. Foran | June 1992 |
| George W. Hoffman | June 1992 |
| Richard H. Stothoff – 2 PHF’s | June 1993 |
| Max Berkowitz | May 1994 |
| Edward J. Mack | May 1995 |
| Stephen Barrick | May 1996 |
| Harrie E. Copeland III | November 1996 |
| Donald R. Bowlby | June 1997 |
| Helen Cantlay | 1998 |
| Robert W. Anderson | June 1998 |
| James Sorrentino | May 1999 |
| Robert L. Burgard | April 1999 |
| Thomas J. Cunningham | 2000 |
| Gwen Doremus-Williams – 3 PHF’s | April 2001 |
| Franklyn H. Barlow | September 2001 |
| Karen Widico | July 2002 |
| Arthur L. Clark “Sandy” | August 2002 |
| Terry M. Ownes – 2 PHF’s | May 2003 |
| Eugene Lupo | June 2004 |
| Teresa Martin | June 2005 |
| Edward G. Zanetti | June 2005 |
| William G. McIntyre (posthumous) | June 2006 |
| Leon Milman (posthumous) | June 2006 |
| Theodore Weinstein | June 2006 |
| Harry Woske | June 2007 |
| Otto A. Reinbacher | July 2007 |
| Harry Mazujian | 2007-08 |
| William Kraus | 2007 |
| Floyd Deardorf | June 2009 |
| Herbert C. Bohler | January 2010 |
| Robert L. Chittenden | June 2010 |
| Michael G. Morris | December 2010 |
| Joseph E. Ziegler | March 2011 |
| James G. Davidson | June 2011 |
| Michael R. Schaible “Mick” | June 2012 |
| Christopher C. Venditti | June 2013 |
| R. Wayne & Wendy Randolph | June 2014 |
| Joseph E. Ziegler | June 2015 |
| Cheryl Copeland | July 2017 |
| Lynn Hyman | July 2016 |
| Darren Loew | June 2017 |
| Kimberly Metz “Kim” | June 2018 |
| Ken Skowronek | 2019 |
| No awards due to the pandemic and recovery | 2020 -2024 |
